Home / Practice Areas / Family Law / Child Custody and Support
Child Custody and Support
Custody turns on the child's best interests. Child support is governed by Indiana's guidelines, with deviations permitted when justified and explained by the court. Knowing the rules changes what you should be asking for.
Legal Custody and Physical Custody
These are two separate things, and conflating them causes more confusion than any other part of a custody case.
Legal custody is decision-making authority — schooling, non-emergency medical care, religious upbringing. Joint legal custody is common and means both parents must confer on those decisions. Physical custody is where the child actually lives. A parent can share joint legal custody while the other parent has primary physical custody, and that arrangement is ordinary rather than a loss.
How Indiana Courts Decide
The standard is the best interests of the child. Indiana law directs the court to consider the child's age and sex; the wishes of the parents; the child's wishes, with more consideration given if the child is at least fourteen years old; the child's relationship with parents, siblings, and others who significantly affect their welfare; the child's adjustment to home, school, and community; the mental and physical health of everyone involved; evidence of domestic violence; and evidence that the child has been cared for by a de facto custodian.
There is no presumption favoring either parent, and there is no presumption for or against equal parenting time. What persuades a court is a concrete record of involvement — who takes the child to appointments, who knows the teachers' names, who handles the morning routine. Clients often arrive convinced the case will turn on the other parent's worst behavior. More often it turns on the quiet documentation of their own.
Parenting Time
Indiana publishes Parenting Time Guidelines that function as the default schedule, including holidays, summer, and how exchanges work. Courts start from them and depart when a family's circumstances justify it.
A parent is entitled to reasonable parenting time unless the court finds it would endanger the child's physical health or significantly impair their emotional development. That is a high bar, and it is not met by the other parent being difficult, irresponsible with money, or newly partnered.
Child Support
Indiana uses an income shares model under the Child Support Guidelines. The calculation considers both parents' incomes, applicable adjustments, childcare and health-insurance costs, and parenting time. The guideline amount is presumptive; deviations require justification and an explanation by the court.
Disputes often concern the inputs — what counts as income for a self-employed parent, whether a parent is voluntarily underemployed and should have income imputed to them, how overnight credit is counted when the schedule is irregular. Those inputs are where a support case is actually litigated.
Modification and Enforcement
Custody can be modified when there has been a substantial change in one or more of the best-interest factors and modification serves the child's best interests. Both halves are required; a change alone is not enough.
Support can be modified when changed circumstances are so substantial and continuing that the existing terms are unreasonable, or when the existing order was issued at least twelve months before the modification petition and differs by more than twenty percent from the guideline amount.
If an order is not followed, enforcement options may include contempt when its legal requirements are met. The appropriate remedy depends on the order, the violation, and the evidence.
One thing worth knowing early: support and parenting time are independent. A parent who is behind on support does not forfeit time with their child, and a parent being denied time does not get to stop paying. Treating one as leverage over the other is the fastest way to lose credibility with a judge.
At a glance
Standard
Best interests of the child
Default schedule
Indiana Parenting Time Guidelines
Support model
Income shares, both incomes
Modification
Substantial, continuing change; or 12 months and more than 20%
Related
Call for a free phone consultation
An honest read on where you stand, before you decide anything.
Consultations by appointment.